A Hamptons rental — and the East-vs-Southampton-vs-Montauk-vs-Sag Harbor decision
The Hamptons isn't one place; it's a string of villages along the South Fork of Long Island, each with its own scene and its own price band.
The Hamptons runs 30 miles along the South Fork of Long Island, from Westhampton in the west to Montauk at the tip. Each village has its own reputation, its own beach access, and its own economic profile. Southampton (the wealthy old-money end). East Hampton (the celebrity + magazine spread). Montauk (surf-and-fisherman-turned-scene). Sag Harbor (the walkable historic port). Where you rent determines the trip more than the region does.
The rental market here is one of the deepest and most expensive in the country. Peak-season weekly rates start around $10K for a 4-bedroom and climb steeply from there. Off-season pricing is dramatically different — spring and fall are the value windows.
Cards below open Vrbo destination results in a new tab. Commissions accrue on completed stays; you pay the same either way.
Vrbo rentals in The Hamptons
New York · category picks from Vrbo's own inventory
Vrbo is a member of the Expedia Group family. destination.com earns a commission on completed bookings — it doesn't change what you pay.
Frequently asked
Which Hamptons village is best for first-time visitors?
Sag Harbor if you want the walkable-Main-Street experience and a real dinner scene without the East Hampton scene tax. Southampton if you want a bigger house on a quieter street. East Hampton if the magazine-spread version is what you're here for. Montauk if the trip is specifically about surfing, fishing, or the party-scene energy.
When should Hamptons rentals be booked?
Peak (Memorial Day through Labor Day) fills 6-9 months out and Saturday-to-Saturday is the norm. The premium weekly Fourth-of-July and Labor Day weeks fill a year in advance. Late-June and September are the shoulder sweet spots — warm ocean, thinner crowds, 30-40% price relief. Off-season (October-May) is a genuinely different, much cheaper Hamptons.
How much do Hamptons rentals cost?
Peak-week 4-bedroom rates start around $10K/week and climb steeply — waterfront estates run $50K+/week. Southampton and East Hampton are the most expensive; Montauk and Sag Harbor run 20-30% less for equivalent quality. Off-season pricing can be 60-70% below peak.