A Fire Island rental — for the car-free barrier island NYC comes to on summer weekends
Fire Island is 32 miles of car-free barrier island off Long Island. Each community is walkable, ferry-accessible, and completely different.
Fire Island is a 32-mile barrier island parallel to Long Island's south shore. No cars on most of the island — you take ferries from Bay Shore, Sayville, or Patchogue and then walk (or bike) between beach and bay. Each of the 17 named communities has its own reputation, its own beach access, and its own summer culture. The famous ones: Cherry Grove and The Pines (the LGBTQ+ communities), Ocean Beach (the walkable town-like community), Fair Harbor and Kismet (family-oriented near the west end).
Four practical bases: Ocean Beach (largest walkable community, family+singles mix), The Pines & Cherry Grove (LGBTQ+ historic destinations), Fair Harbor / Kismet (family-quiet west end), Saltaire / Point O'Woods (quiet residential).
Cards below open Vrbo destination results in a new tab. Commissions accrue on completed stays; you pay the same either way.
Vrbo rentals in Fire Island
New York · category picks from Vrbo's own inventory
Vrbo is a member of the Expedia Group family. destination.com earns a commission on completed bookings — it doesn't change what you pay.
Frequently asked
Which Fire Island community is best for first-time visitors?
Ocean Beach if you want the most town-like walkable experience. The Pines or Cherry Grove for LGBTQ+ visitors. Fair Harbor or Kismet for a family week. Saltaire for the quiet-old-money version.
Are there really no cars on Fire Island?
Mostly correct. Most communities are car-free — you walk or bike. There are some exceptions (fire trucks, service vehicles, a couple of communities like Robbins Rest that allow limited resident cars). Ferries are the standard access; some communities have taxi service between them.
When should Fire Island rentals be booked?
Peak (Memorial Day through Labor Day) fills 6-9 months out. Fourth of July week fills a year in advance. Weekly Saturday-to-Saturday is the standard cadence. Ferry service is limited off-season (October-May); Fire Island is essentially a summer-only rental market.